Myth: The United States created the Taliban

Posted on


A common misconception, wantonly cultivated by liberals who think America deserves all the bad stuff she gets, is that the US created the Taliban by supporting the Mujihadeen in their fight against the Soviets.

In fact, nearly the opposite is true.

The evolution of the Taliban and al-Qaeda is exceedingly complicated, primarily because they are not state actors, but smaller groups of religious zealots acted upon and acting through many states.

I’ll simplify for the purposes of this blog and because I have so little time.

The Taliban initially began as a religious student movement, which erupted when former Mujihadeen commanders and fighters committed a series of atrocities during the civil wars that ensued after the Soviet defeat. While some Taliban actions occurred as early as 1994, it was Mullah Omar that gave the movements coherence when he seized the Cloak of the Prophet in Kandahar and declared himself commander of the faithful. From there, the Taliban essentially went on to become the victor of the Afghan civil war. For all of their brutality, they at least represented law, and they were consistent as well as brutal in the application of that law.

Again, stacks of books have been written on the matter of Afghanistan. But let me just say, that saying that the US created the Taliban by funding the Mujihadeen is a massive over-simplication and obfuscation. There were afterall, lots of Mujihadeen who were not Taliban. Most of them, actually. To say we created the Taliban would be akin to saying that Columbine High school created the murderers Klebold and Harris. Yes they went to school there. Yes, the school fed them lunch and taught them. But they did that to others who didn’t commit mass murder, too.

The accusation that we helped bad people and they came back to bite us is an obsfucation also. We helped lots of good people too. Some bad people were in the mix, and as bad people tend to do, they crushed the weak. The eduacted and moderates fled the country.

So, the Taliban is a separate entity from the Mujihadeen, though there are members of the Muj in the Taliban. The actions of the Taliban are only an example that the world always has its bad players and you deal with them as they come along. Pakistan, the ISI, Saudi Arabia, all of these entities funded the Taliban directly, and indeed backed their ideological vision of Sharia for all.

Advertisements

One thought on “Myth: The United States created the Taliban

    Amos Volante said:
    August 14, 2010 at 2:10 pm

    The Gypsies could have reached the same status if they had a popular religion and a common enemy with states from whom they needed support.

    Really, you could make your local Teetotalers Club like the Taliban if the state/religion/common enemy recipe could be made the same.

    “Hear ye, hear ye, today we march against the mall!”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s